5 Best Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI

5 Best Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI

As a company that focuses on providing the best attic insulation and ventilation products, it’s important for us to understand all variables that can impact our products’ performance.

One major component to creating a healthy, comfortable, and efficient attic is the roof. During our attic inspections, we carefully assess the roof to ensure that there is adequate ventilation and that there are no structural issues. The last thing that we want is to put in brand new insulation only to have it damaged because of a roof leak!

Over the years, we’ve learned a thing or two about the roofing industry in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. In this article, we’ll share our expert advice on how to choose the best roofing company for your Milwaukee home. We’ll also provide a shortlist of the best contractors to streamline your vetting process.

Top Milwaukee, WI Roofing Companies

Based on our experience, research, and public reviews, here are the top Milwaukee roofing contractors:

BCI Exteriors

Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI - BCI Exteriors

Contact Information:

About BCI Exteriors:

BCI Exteriors has delivered a wide array of residential and commercial roofing options since 1979. The company’s certified technicians install wood shake, asphalt, and composition shingles, metal, and rubber on a variety of roof angles and shapes.

They also offer their expertise on commercial applications that range from flat roofs requiring coatings, such as TPO or PVC to churches and apartment complexes.

  • 7-star rating on Google [90 reviews]
  • A+ Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating
  • GAF Master Elite Weather-Stopper Roofing Contractor
  • Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor
  • Member of MBA, NARI, GuildQuality & HomeAdvisor

Guardian, INC.

Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI - Guardian Home Improvements

Contact Information:

About Guardian, INC.:

Guardian is a full-service residential and commercial construction company. They specialize in full exterior services: Roofing, Siding, Windows, Carpentry, & Masonry. Guardian is competitively priced and services all of South Eastern Wisconsin, the Milwaukee-metro area.

Their focus is on preventing and resolving problems related to building design, specifications, and construction.

Team Guardian is comprised of Local and National Construction Industry and related professionals. Guardian’s mission is to provide Home Owners with a “ Better Way to Buy Home Improvements “, eliminate all the Risk’s typically associated with the home improvement process, and deliver construction projects that exceed expectations.

  • 8-star rating on Google [195 reviews]
  • A+ Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating
  • 27+ years in business
  • Certified by EnergyStar.gov, NARI & National Fenestration Rating Council
  • Offers commercial, and residential roofing, siding, windows & doors solutions as well as consulting services

A Custom To, LLC.

Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI - A Custom To

Contact Information:

About A Custom To, LLC.:

A Custom To LLC is a residential roofing company near Milwaukee. It has provided comprehensive services since 1999. The company is a preferred contractor for GAF and Owens Corning in addition to partnering with such quality manufacturers as TAMKO, John Manville, and Karnak Systems.

In addition to installing the roofing materials, its certified technicians ensure flashings, ice and water shields, vents, and gutters are at optimal performance.

  • 9-star rating on Google [69 reviews]
  • A+ Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating
  • 23+ years in business
  • GAF Certified™ Roofer
  • Top 10 list of Expertise’s Best Roofers in Milwaukee 2022

Community Roofing & Restoration

Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI - Community Roofing & Restoration

Contact Information:

About Community Roofing & Restoration:

With over 100 5-star reviews on Google, Community Roofing & Restoration is a full-service roofing company that has been serving Milwaukee and the surrounding areas of Southeastern Wisconsin for more than 40 years.

Their team is comprised of artisans and skilled craftsmen at the top of their trades. They’re also backed by the support of roofing industry juggernauts such as CertainTeed, Mulehide, and DaVinci. So no matter how big or small the project is, they have the skills and expertise needed to tackle it.

  • 7-star rating on Google [116 reviews]
  • 40+ Years in Business
  • A+ Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating
  • Completed 9000+ projects in Milwaukee and the surrounding areas
  • Top 10 list of Expertise’s Best Roofers in Milwaukee 2022

Allrite Home & Remodeling

Roofing Companies in Milwaukee, WI - Allrite Home & Remodeling

Contact Information:

About Allrite Home & Remodeling:

Allrite Home & Remodeling is a family-owned and family-operated company that has been serving clients in Milwaukee and nearby areas since 1969. It provides roofing services that include the installation, removal, and replacement of asphalt shingle, cedar, metal, and slate roofs.

Its crew handles materials from a variety of manufacturers that include CertainTeed, GAF, DaVinci, and Malarkey.

The company has adopted an 11-point project management process that emphasizes open communication with clients. Referrals and repeat customers account for the majority of its business.

  • 5-star rating on Google [47 reviews]
  • 50+ years in business
  • A+ Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating
  • NARI® Certified Professionals on Staff
  • Gives back to the community

Milwaukee, WI Roofing Overview

With a population of approximately 594,548 in Milwaukee, WI, and the average roof lasting approximately 20 years, you pretty much can’t drive down the street without seeing someone putting up a new roof. Along with projects like HVAC and window replacement, roofing is one of the best long-term investments for homeowners in Milwaukee.

But the tightly confined geography of the market creates a challenging market space for roofing companies and contractors. Rising national material and labor costs, combined with local competition and increased marketing expenditures are some of the biggest obstacles in 2021.

Did you know that the average roofing company pays $22 per click on Google? That’s just to get a potential customer to simply click on their ad and to navigate to their website. A roofing company can pay well over $2000 in ad expense just for clicks, which don’t guarantee leads or appointments. These high price tags to get in front of in-market buyers (Milwaukee homeowners shopping for a new roof) are indicators of an ultra-competitive market. To make a profit and run a healthy business, roofing companies and contractors are looking at charging more for their product, services, and experience.

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Roof in Milwaukee?

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Roof in Milwaukee, WI?

Roof replacement costs in Milwaukee, meaning removing your current roofing material and replacing it, are about $5,800 to $10,000.

Removing the roof is a process in and of itself, costing about $1 to $5 per square foot removal or about $1000 to $1,500 total. Contractors can also charge by the hour for this process at around $40 to $80 per hour. Furthermore, if your roof has rotting timbers or other waste, it can add a few thousand dollars to the removal cost.

It’s important to know that removal is a big part of the entire replacement process, as taking shingles off of a rooftop is a difficult task for anyone – professional or otherwise. Therefore, a contractor’s rate can fluctuate based on the material being removed, your location, and the complexity of the overall work.

How to Choose a Milwaukee, WI Roofing Contractor

How to Choose a Roofing Contractor or Company

There are many roofing companies in Milwaukee and it can be overwhelming when trying to choose one. As a general rule of thumb, we recommend getting at least 3 estimates prior to making a decision.

With roof replacement being a longtime investment, getting the right crew is extremely important. Here are some things to keep in mind when choosing your provider.

Lifetime Warranty

A lifetime warranty guarantees that the product you received from a business won’t fail, and if it does, the service provider will replace and repair their initial work. A lifetime warranty from a roofing company shows confidence in their work, and the warranty can also be transferred to subsequent owners of your home should you choose to sell it.

Full Transparency

Try to find a business that will discuss every detail of the roofing procedure without sugarcoating anything. This not only shows their dedication but also their trustworthiness as service providers.

It’s a good sign if a contractor communicates effectively, or if they are willing to clarify terms that you don’t know. Follow-up and professionalism are something to pay attention to during the vetting process.

Reviews and Ratings

Go online and check a provider’s Better Business Bureau rating. These ratings show how well the business interacts with its customers. BBB often tracks how long a business has been operational, their transparency with customers, and even their history of complaints and how they were dealt with.

BBB has a comprehensive rating system designed to inform users with a full understanding of how well a roofing provider serves its customers. Beyond the BBB, check out your potential roofing company’s website, Facebook page, Google reviews, and any other third-party ratings. The more reviews and higher the ratings, the more you can rest assured that you will get a quality job.

Bonus Tips

Don’t forget about what’s under your roof

When taking on a roof replacement project, it’s easy to become consumed with the necessary details to get it done, including choosing the right materials, finding a great contractor, and staying within budget.

You can very easily lose sight of other home improvements that need to get done. With that being said, it’s often easier (and more cost-effective) to work on similar home projects at the same time. One thing that many homeowners should think about as they plan a roof replacement is whether they need to upgrade attic insulation.

If you’re already taking on a roof replacement, it’s the perfect time to schedule a free attic inspection to see if you need to upgrade your insulation. Killing two birds with one stone doesn’t just save you the hassle of taking on two separate renovations. You also gain energy efficiency benefits that will save you money year-round in the Pennsylvania climate.

Remember, putting a brand new roof on your home without taking care of the stuff directly under it is like putting lipstick on a pig.

Are You a Roofer in Milwaukee?

Are you a roofer in Milwaukee? Looking for ways to get more exposure and generate qualified leads for your roofing business? Want to diversify your digital marketing strategy without the hassle?

At Attics and More, we offer a unique LIMITED opportunity for select Milwaukee roofing companies to increase brand exposure, boost credibility, and generate more leads and sales.

If you feel like you are one of the BEST roofing companies in Milwaukee, we want to hear from you. Email us at to see if you qualify to get featured on this list.

Frequently Asked Questions

How to choose a good roofing company?

There are a number of different things you can do to ensure that you choose a good roofing company. Consider first asking friends, family, and neighbors for referrals. Also, look at popular review sites including Facebook, Google, Home Advisor, Thumbtack, and Yelp. Ensure that the company that you’re looking to hire has a consistent, positive review score across multiple platforms.

Also, as a general rule of thumb, you should meet with at least three roofing companies and get estimates from each. Don’t give in to high-pressure sales tactics. Shop around and ask contractors how they are different.

What is the most common roof type in Milwaukee?

The most common residential roofing material used in Milwaukee are asphalt shingles. These are popular because they are economical and easy to install. Asphalt shingles can be reinforced with fiberglass or organic materials (cellulose) without changing the appearance of the shingle.

How long do roofs last in Milwaukee?

The lifespan of a roof in Milwaukee will ultimately depend on the type of roofing material used. In general, homes with asphalt shingle roofs will typically last between 20-25 years. Tile roofs can last much longer, sometimes up to 50 years.

Explore More Wisconsin Roofing Companies

We are constantly evaluating new areas and the best roofing companies to help us market our products and services. We also pride ourselves on being able to share our findings with the public to make the process of finding and hiring a roofer a little easier.

Many of the companies that we list have successfully grown to service multiple locations across the State. Browse more of the best Wisconsin roofing companies to see how the results vary from city to city: